Elly May's Critter Sitters Logo Cat

Safe. Sincere. Dependable.
In-Your-Home Pet Sitting.

Animals give our lives meaning and purpose. They share in our joy and they comfort us in our times of sorrow. It’s tough to be away from our furry friends, but when those instances are needed, you can trust Elly May’s Critter Sitters to care for your pets like they were our own. We promise to love, care for and keep your pets’ routine - just like you would.
Learn More
Fluffy puppy sleeping

Wanna Get Started? It’s EASY!


About Elly's

Elly May’s Critter Sitters LLC are local, SW Florida residents, pet owners and animal lovers. We are honest, dependable, reliable, and professional mature adults. All of our Sitters are screened and personally trained prior to contracting. We are licensed, bonded, and insured - all for your complete security and peace of mind.
Learn More
Elly May's Critter Cab

Serving Select Areas From Venice To Sarasota.

Elly May’s Critter Sitters specialize in the following areas of Venice; Sarasota National, Islandwalk, Gran Paradiso, Renaissance, The Preserve and Oasis.
Areas ServedPaw PrintsBouncer the Frog
Why did the frog say meow?
He was learning a foreign language.

Getting Started is EASY!



Elly May's Critter Sitters is all about your pets - walking, overnight sitting, vet trips, frisbee tosses - whatever your pet needs they find a way to accommodate. Our little cockapoo loves Staci so much that she chases cars that look like the Elly May van when we're out walking, hoping to catch up for a little bit of Staci's attention. We've gone on trips short and long without a concern for our fur babies. We come home to healthy, happy pups who probably wish we had stayed away longer! If you are looking for a pet service you can rely on, don't hesitate to call on the Elly May's team. They are the best in the business.

Ellen/Tim Foster

Sophie & Ellie

Staci and Elly May's Critter Sitters have been an absolute treasure to work with and to have in our lives! The care, the concern and love that has been shown to not only our dogs, but to our family as a whole, has been extraordinary. We have worked together for 7 years (daily dog waking, occasional vet appointments and overnight pet sitting) and despite our second dog's recent passing, we still stay in touch. She is a wonderful person and her business is a reflection of that. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a kind person with a huge heart to help with the care of their animals! They say a picture is worth 1000 words… Just take a look at her photo gallery in her phone and it will speak volumes! I don't think there's a human in any of those pictures. Just adorable pictures of all of her furry clients! She treats these cherished animals like they are her own!

Justin/Jaime Lee

Daisy & General

I have been using Staci with Ellie May's Critter Sitters for 7 plus years. She is an absolute delight. Always takes excellent care of my fur babies, going above and beyond and so helpful with my ever changing schedule. I was looking for a pet sitter / walker, what I got was a friend.

Charmae Billingham

Bimini/Tiki & Fatfat

View More Testimonialscat peeking
What do you call a pile of kittens?
A meowntain!

Contact Elly

Drop Us A Line or Give Us A Ring:

If you have any questions or would like to schedule your FREE "Meet & Greet" with Staci and one of our sitters, please contact us.

Donate & Volunteer

A portion of all of our profits are donated to help the adoption of homeless, neglected and abused animals of all species. Visit all of our friends below, and please, donate your time or money. They really do amazing work and the world is a better place because of their tremendous work.
Give BackGray Dog
Elly Mays Logo
Copyright © 2024 | Elly May's Critter Sitters | Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Sitemap